If roosevelt’s judicial reform had been passed, how would new judges have been appointed?


Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 407 People


If Roosevelt’s judicial reform had been passed, how would new judges have been appointed?
on the basis of the years of experiences of sitting judges
on the basis of the age of sitting judges
on the basis of the workload of the Supreme Court
on the basis of the will of the people on the basis of the number who had retired

Answered by maham237 @



Correct answer: on the basis of the age of sitting judges.

Context/explanation:

President Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR) was eager to implement his New Deal programs as an antidote to the Great Depression. However, the US Supreme Court had already ruled that some provisions of the New Deal were unconstitutional, because they took too much power into the hands of the federal government, especially the executive branch of the federal government. So, riding the momentum of his landslide reelection victory in 1936, in February of 1937, FDR proposed a plan to expand the Supreme Court to as many as 15 judges. The plan offered to provide full pay to justices over age 70 who would retire. If the older justices didn't retire, assistant justices (with full voting rights) would be appointed to sit with those existing justices. This was a way FDR hoped to give the court a liberal majority that would side with his programs.

As it turned out, before FDR's proposal came up for a vote in Congress, two of the sitting justices came over to his side of the argument, and the Supreme Court narrowly approved as constitutional both the Social Security Act and the National Labor Relations Act. So his plan (which failed in the US Senate) became unnecessary to his purposes.

Roosevelt's "court-packing" scheme was unpopular. It was seen as an attempt to take away the independence of the judicial branch of government.


Similar Questions

How did critics view the judicial reform bill under roosevelt

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 274 persons

How did critics view the judicial reform bill under Roosevelt?

Which best describes the public/private partnerships created under roosevelt’s new deal reforms?

Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 484 persons

Which best describes the public/private partnerships created under Roosevelt’s New Deal reforms? The government took ownership of large private businesses. The government put management of large companies up for a …

Which explains how roosevelt modeled his new deal programs after progressive reforms?

Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 467 persons

Which explains how Roosevelt modeled his New Deal programs after Progressive reforms? A. He designed programs that kept government interference in the economy at a minimum and allowed consumers to …

Theodore roosevelt warned william howard taft that tariff reform would

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 260 persons

Which candidate unexpectedly tried to gain the Republican nomination from Taft when Taft’s first term ended?

How did the supreme court frustrate roosevelt's new deal legislation

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 320 persons

How did the Supreme Court frustrate Roosevelt’s New Deal legislation? by declaring some of it unconstitutional by sending it back to Congress by suggesting a judicial reform bill by upholding …

A good clue that a judge is practicing judicial activism is when he or she _____.

Asked by maham237 @ in Social Studies viewed by 316 persons

A good clue that a judge is practicing judicial activism is when he or she _____. interprets the law based on the Constitution interprets the law according to newer values …

Many americans feared that immigrants who passed through angel island would

Asked by wiki @ in History viewed by 569 persons

a have to return to their home countries. b assimilate into American culture. c claim American land to build farms. d take jobs from Americans workers. 2.In the mid- to …

Which was a new deal program instituted by franklin roosevelt

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 301 persons

Which was a new deal program instituted by franklin roosevelt

If i are you i would easily pass this test

Asked by admin @ in English viewed by 351 persons

ALMOST NO ONE CAN PASS THE TOUGHEST Grammar test.Can YOU? 1)_____book is this?a)Whose b)Who'sc)Not sure2)_____going to party tonight?a)Whoseb)Who'sc)Who isd)None of these3)You and …

Overcoming fixed mindset: a step-by-step guide to cultivating a growth mindset

Asked by wiki @ in Health viewed by 1267 persons

Which of the following would best complete this list?

Asked by wiki @ in Social Studies viewed by 731 persons

What had the king decided to do before he saw the spider

Asked by vanshika149 @ in English viewed by 1125 persons

Describe the karez in your own words

Asked by rajesh064 @ in English viewed by 1291 persons

Most viewed questions in History


Candle making in colonial america reading answers test 5 answers

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 11326 persons


Lowman consulting answer key

Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 5151 persons


Lets grow with composite mathematics class 8 solutions pdf

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 3197 persons



Venezuelans started buying items immediately because of their fear of

Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 2526 persons


Commonlit teaching shakespeare in a maximum security prison answer key

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 2259 persons


4.3 puzzle time answers algebra 2

Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 2094 persons



Why did the termite like expensive hotels worksheet answer key

Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 1956 persons


On which day are your answering stats reset

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 1856 persons


Why did king kong eat a truck worksheet answer key

Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 1748 persons



Two ways of looking at a river commonlit answers key

Asked by maham237 @ in History viewed by 1662 persons


Which occurs during disequilibrium? check all that apply.

Asked by wiki @ in History viewed by 1648 persons



What is taplow's opinion about the greek tragedy agamemnon

Asked by admin @ in History viewed by 1407 persons


What is the topic of the info grapher

Asked by jesus643 @ in History viewed by 1379 persons